[quote="bburton"]Dane,
Here's an example of how I interpret what you suggest. This pic was taken: 1/200 f4 -0.7ev 9.7mm. Then I resized to 800X600, bumped contrast and brightness by 12% and sharpened one notch.
What do you think? I know it's too dark, but if I don't cut down on the initial exposure (-0.7ev), then it seems my outside pictures have a real contrast problem from the get go (in this case, dark locomotive and white, overcast sky). Any suggestions with this challenge?
I don't think the pic looks all that dark. It looks a pic of the train on an overcast day. In fact..I think you did a good job handling the difficult exposure problem.
The photo is tack sharp too.
I have been doing some experimenting with my 717 using the spot meter and a flash unit. I have been working on getting faces nicely exposed againts a bright blue or overcast sky. I point the crosshairs of the spot meter at the brightest part of the composition. With some minor adjustments I find a happy medium between the sky and the subject, with the subject a tad on the dark side. Then I lock the AE on the camera, recompose and shoot, hitting the faces with the flash. More times than not, this method has worked well for me. Here is one example....
I had trouble with this shot of my son, Joe, because I kept burning out the bright white helmet while underexposing his face. I switched to spot meter, aimed the crosshairs at the bright helmut, hit the AE lock, recomposed to the shot with the onboard flash on full. The result is a well exposed helmut, natural looking background, and good facial features that otherwise would have been lost in shadow.
Now I know that this is a different shooting scenario than shooting the train on a cloudy day, but try experimenting with the spot meter to find a happy medium between background and subject. Put the the EV back up to 0 and try it, too. Again...your train shot looks fine to me. It is what my eye would have seen, shadows and all, If I had been standing next to you on that cloudy day.
Regards,
Dane (definitely not a camera whiz kid) I just keep shooting until something works.