Okay everyone, GREAT dialogue here.
Hit pause and I'll finish the story as briefly as possible - cliff notes version...(and it's STILL long)
MIL gets photos...
MIL presents photo to the "team" for selection...
MIL: Wow those are awesome! (insert team member name) was just wondering if you have any other shots we could look at.
Me: What's wrong with the ones we sent?
MIL: Oh nothing, they're great, we just wanted something a little different.
Me: I thought you didn't have anything in mind.
MIL: Well we don't but remember you said Z was a possibility?
Me: Well yes, so was X and Y which I sent you.
MIL: Yeah well we were really wanting to see Z too.
Me: Why didn't you tell me that?
MIL: Well you know how women are, but your other shots are SO good I'm sure Z will be exactly what we want.
Me: Okay...sure.
So wifey and I set up another shoot - outdoors this time at a local shopping center - and purchase over $100 in new winter clothes just for the shoot - and shoot for about 2 more hours.
Add in another 3-4 hours culling pics with the wife again...

And perfectly retouching the selections...

(why? because MIL was coming up to the deadline fast and promised whatever we sent would be used, no question about it...)
And I send the next round of photos off...
Good news though: Wife LOVES her pictures this time - they are exactly what SHE had in mind the whole time as well.
Cool - we did what MIL wants, wife is happy, all good...
No reply for 2 days, so I follow-up by email...
Me: So which image did you decide on?
MIL: Well we're sort of torn, they're all so good.
Me: Cool, at least you have what you need and plenty to choose from.
MIL: Well, actually, the new shots are too good.
Me: Come again?
MIL: We tried several on the magazine cover and we think it looks like an ad for JCPenny or a fashion catalog cover.
Me: So you don't like them because they are too hi-end?
MIL: No we really love them!
Me: I'll rephrase: So you're not going to use ANY of them?
MIL: No I guess not. But we were talking about it and looking over all the photos again and we decided this one photo from the first group would be absolutely perfect if (wife) was just smiling.
Me: Well I have about 8 hours in this "free" project so far but if you're 101% sure this is a go, I'll do it.
MIL: Oh wow that's awesome. Yes, we're absolutely sure.
Chalk up another hour or so perfectly retouching another (smiling) face onto the image...
And off it goes to MIL...
No reply for another two days so I followup by email...
Me: We haven't heard from you, so I guess the last image was a go?
MIL: Well not really.
Me: You're joking.
MIL: I know, I know - this is so ridiculous. See here's what happened: (name) actually didn't like any of the photos the entire time but the rest of us did so we've been trying to talk her into them...
Me: (and you never mentioned this..?!?!?!)
MIL: ...so I finally pinned her down on what she wanted. She actually found this really nice image on Flickr that she wanted to use.
Me: (shoot me now) oh really, what was it?
MIL: Well it wasn't like anything we talked about so far - it was totally different, in the big city, at night, with snow falling....
Me: (shoot me again)
MIL: ...anyhow she finally tracked down the photographer and she's just an amateur living in California - or Japan, I can't remember - anyhow the lady was really excited because she doesn't shoot professionally and just got lucky with that photo but now she thinks it could be a new career for her and she's really excited so we're waiting on her to send us the photo.
Me: okay - glad you got it worked out - good luck with the project.
another couple of days go by...
MIL: Hey, did you retouch that photo yet? We really need it now.
Me: What photo are you talking about and what happened to the other photo you found on Flickr?
MIL: Oh THAT photo...no that didn't work out. She sent it to us and it was 200K file size. We asked her for the full resolution version and she had no idea what we were talking about and sent the only one she had.
Me: (I'd be laughing at this point if I weren't crying...) ok so which one of my photos are you referring to
MIL: You know the very, very first one we talked about. I told you that one would be perfect if you just fixed her eyes, put a smile on that face too, and retouch in a different background - like a warm cozy fireplace setting or something.
Me: Well you never told me ANY of that, and I just can't put even that much more time into this without some kind of compensation. This is the X-th change you've made and I have absolutely no faith you're not going to keep doing this until the cows come home. I love you as my MIL but I'm done with this project.
MIL: (mildly offended) okay I understand
a few more days elapse...
Me: So what ever happened with the cover?
MIL: Oh we used that photo.
Me: So who did the retouching?
MIL: No one, we ran it as is.
Me: You're joking again right? What about the eyes and background?
MIL: Oh I just left them like they were, we didn't have time to mess with it.
Me:
So in the end...
They used one of the weakest photos we sent them...
They ran it completely unretouched...
It was from the group my wife HATED and was the photo she HATED MOST...
Wife is ticked...
MIL is ticked...
All her "team" at the magazine are ticked...
And I didn't make a dime...
AND I'm out 10+ hours...
AND I spend over $100 in clothes (which I insisted my wife keep as some consolation...)
So naturally...I'M TICKED!!!
Well, that's the story. I hope you learn the following lessons from my hard knocks...
1. Never work for free - especially for family
2. Never accept the answer "just do whatever you want, I'm sure we'll love it."
Oh yeah, last weekend I shot a few pics of my Sister-in-Law for her facebook and dating pages as she is going through a nasty divorce. Naturally, I didn't charge her and what happened? She hated them and didn't use them...
This is me > Stupid

Stupid

STUPID
Don't be ME !!!!