Ok, so here is my "review" of the class.
First of all, let me get this out of the way. The class was excellent, and I learned a TON of stuff!
For those of you who could not attend. Here is the outline we followed:
http://www.polodigital.net/Lighting/...emoOutline.pdf
I'm going to use that as a reference for my "critique".
Scott did an excellent job explaining and answering everyone's questions in section two. This was really the meat of the class in my mind, and this was the information most valuable in my mind.
Section 3 was mostly common sense as far as looking in magazines and basically checking out other photo's for ideas, etc.. But Scott showed some specific books that are now on my must have list. In addition, the "my equipment" list was a nice touch.
Section 4, 5, and 6, which were the shooting sessions is where in my VERY humble opinion, we could do some improvements.
Basically after the lighting was setup and Scott did an excellent job showing everyone how to setup the lights. What to look for as far as shadows, he repeatedly covered how the larger the light sources in relation to the subject, the softer the light. How to fill, rim/hair, the whole nine yards. Even flash metering was gone over in GREAT detail.
However, when it was turned over us to start shooting the structure of the class was interrupted. This did not effect the quality of the class, what changed is that one person would be modeling, one shooting, a couple watching, and then some more crowded by the computer. Different topics discussed amongst many people spread out.
I guess my opinion is that shooting was not required on my part. I shot one or two of the setups, but since this class was on lighting, and not posing or taking the pictures, the actual process of me going up and clicking off a few pictures was an unnecessary portion of the class.
What I would have rather seen is similar to what they did in a very basic Nikon class I attended one time.
Basically Scott controls everything. He sets up the lights and explains why they are setup the way they were. Take some pictures. We all see the results. And then different lights modifiers are applied, more shots are taken by Scott and results compared by us. Questions answers, rinse and repeat. The way they did this in the Nikon class, is the D70 has a composite output that they just plugged into a TV. So every shot taken was instantly displayed on the television set.
The only reason I'd prefer that method, is that I think we could have gone through more of the light modifiers, and seen a few more examples, and maybe even had a little more time for a short workflow review.
Hopefully this isn't coming off as a complaint. I know I had a few Margaritas at dinner tonight. I only mention this because it felt like the pace of the class slowed a bit once Scott was not directly controlling everyone’s attention.
I would also mention that I would have gladly paid double to have 1/2 the people in attendance. I know Scott wasn't making any money off of this and it's not reasonable to have him teach twice as many classes. But 10 people, especially with all 10 people shooting every set left for some downtime. Which admittedly was nice for socializing.
Section 7 was covered adequatley. I especially enjoyed learning about Scott progression in working with models, and a bit of the business behind model/photographer/make up artist relationship.
All in all, I was extremely pleased with the class!!!
Excellent job Scott. I can't thank you enough for taking your own personal time and sharing it with us!