Well. I will go ahead and say what was going on and how we fixed it.
In this gallery here I have 2 odd size pics and I wanted to change the options on just those 2.
http://jakemckeephotography.exposure...om/g/rt-conrad
The password is: cutebaby
Every time I tried it would change every pic in the gallery. So what I had to do was click on the picture and then go to the menu were it says "photo" then "Edit Sales Options" and then pick from a drop down the "Yes, override gallery settings".
That last part was what I was missing.
It was very easy, I was just not thinking that hard.