Help me pick a new logo for my bridal boutique!

[HotHolly]

We recently hired a graphic designer to redo our bridal boutique's logo.

Here is our old logo (minus the address):


Here are the new logos the came up with. We can choose one and revise it until we love it.

Let me know which one is your favorite AND which one you totally hate.

PS - If you like our old logo better than any of the new ones, let me know that too.

#1


#2


#3


#4


#5


#6

[ChristopherCoy]

Thats a hard choice.

#1 Looks very young and teeny bopper-ish, also kinda nursery/baby-ish
#2 Looks very plastic and barbi-ish
#3 Is very simple, elegant, and sophisticated.
#4 Looks a little more "high fashion"
#5 Is another very simple, elegant, and sophisticated design.
#6 Reminds me of the Balleys Fitness Logo.

For me, I think I like #5 the best. It would look really nice on a fine quality business card, executive letterhead, or an advertisement in a high end catalog.

[texkam]

These all look like quality concepts. I'd listen to your designer. If the design process was handled properly your designer should have spent more time than any of us getting to know you and your business and exactly what you are trying to convey.

[ka5txl]

I prefer the old logo, but I had to choose a new one I would go with #5 as it seems to best of the new ones. I don't care for #1, #2, or #6 and don't feel that #3 or #4 as as good as #5.

[bondarnes]

I voted for 5, but also like 4 very much.

[CaptainTom]

1-6-5 hate the rest.

[HotHolly]

Thanks for the feedback. Keep it coming - especially any women in here!!!

HotHolly added 5 Minutes and 30 Seconds later...Double Post Merged Below

Originally Posted by CaptainTom

1-6-5 hate the rest.

Dont you talk about my old logo like that!!! jk.

[BeccaJ]

5 is my favorite. dont like 6, but i like it better than 2. 4 is pretty cool too. 3's elegant but not as much as 5.

[HotHolly]

Which logo has the best recall?

If you arent sure...Close your eyes. Which one pops up clearly in your memory in full detail w/ out going back and peeking?

[LEO III]

What I really like is your original logo, but with the italic font and lettering that you have in #5, and reducing the size of the entire logo to the size of #5.

[carrbowl]

I like 5 the best...looks like someone I would trust to do business with, someone with some style, some class..someone I could trust. But as far as recall...it would be the first one with the 3 B's...because it made me think about the 3 b's , but I don't think it fits you...more for babies, than bridals..

[ka5txl]

Ok I haven't peeked, I still prefer the original, but #5 still pops in my mind

[J Eddington]

#5 or #4 WITHOUT the cinderella chick.

[photopam]

#5 just looks the best. I think it says it is a very upscale bridal boutique, one with class and poise and most reflects the image you have now (based solely on your current logo). The others are nice, but they do not seem to have the same high quality feel that #5 does. #6 is alright too, but with different colors and lose the circle.

Hope this helps!

[BillMellett]

I would probably go with 5 just because it retains the style of the old logo so that you kind of have some continuity in the minds of your customers.