Yummers! Pie! I'm with the other pie lovers there.
In reading your description of the event, I have the sense that a lot more was going on than a lady with flour on her fingers, or a table of pies. There were people here involved in knowing each other. As Jordan said, use your wide angle and get in close.
For instance, as Milton pointed out, there are people cooking. Maybe you could get down low, find a shot where you could have someone eating pie on the side of the frame, and in the other 2/3 of the frame show people talking, cooking, or whatever social interaction is going on. Use a deep DOF so the viewer can see all the activity.
Fill the frame, especially 1/3 of it. This is a poor example, but it might give you some idea what I mean:
Or maybe a shot from a strange angle - find a ladder. Or, if people are involved in an activity, possibly take a shot over their shoulder.
Now - you gotta tell us when the next wild game dinner is going to happen - I want to be there!